Blog

The emperor’s new savings: Nine lessons on AI pricing in professional services

| min Lesedauer
ai pricing

Clients expect AI to make professional services cheaper. At the same time, firms need to fund the technology that makes delivery more efficient. Drawing on two years of AI pricing experience and recent discussions with industry leaders, we share nine lessons on who pays the AI bill – and who actually gets the savings.

In Hans Christian Andersen’s 19th-century fairy tale, everyone admires the emperor’s magnificent new clothes. Everyone talks about them. But no one dares to say they do not exist, for fear of looking incompetent or stupid – until a little child asks the uncomfortable question: where, exactly, are they?

The conversation about AI savings in professional services risks following a similar script. Clients expect faster, more automated delivery to translate into lower fees. Yet the financial benefits can be considerably harder to identify – and to distribute.

Both sides have a legitimate claim: clients funding their own technology look for savings elsewhere, including on external advisers, while firms need to recover their technology costs without losing competitiveness.

This tension is central to most of our current conversations with leaders from professional services firms.

The question is no longer only “How do we defend our fees when AI makes work faster?” An equally pressing question is: “Who pays the AI bill while everyone is already expecting the savings?”

AI economics: Real costs, unproven savings

Unlike the emperor’s clothes, AI costs are very real – even if they often sit with central IT rather than with the teams delivering the work. The savings are not yet proven, and someone has to pay for the technology first.

1. The AI hype is still ahead of the measurable economic reality

Most leaders we spoke to expect AI-driven efficiency gains to arrive in the years ahead. Their fee expectations are more mixed: some anticipate stable or slightly higher fees (e.g., by moving higher up the value chain or expanding scope), while others expect slightly lower fees as clients ask for their share of the savings.

Meanwhile, only a few firms report a meaningful rise in profitability. Saved time does not automatically remove cost: freed-up capacity is redeployed, and AI spending keeps climbing.

2. Before sharing the benefits, establish who funds them

Firms first need to decide which AI costs sit centrally and which each engagement carries.

To recover costs, firms turn to a tech surcharge, higher rates – a trend that we see at some law firms – or a “digital employee” proposition that sells a specified amount of AI-enabled work in capacity units clients recognize. As we explored in Services as software: Why AI is rewriting the commercial logic of business services, such models let clients buy AI-enabled work the way they already buy services.

3. Innovative pricing models often fail at the client’s procurement desk

Procurement wants comparability, budget control, and transparency – and rate cards deliver all three. New fees or charging units can therefore meet resistance, even for a compelling service.

Offers that succeed define outputs, expected spend, volume assumptions, and rules for extra work. Clients avoid an open-ended AI bill, and firms can still charge for delivery costs that are no longer human labor.

Pricing and offer architecture: Price the garment, not the stitching

The emperor’s tailor who buys a sewing machine faces a familiar problem. Charge only for stitching time, and faster production can reduce revenue while introducing new costs. The machine may be an excellent investment – but the charging logic needs to keep up.

The fix is not a more convincing story about invisible clothes. It is clarity about what is delivered, what it costs, and why the client values it.

4. The right price level often beats a sophisticated pricing model

Start with the real costs – technology usage, implementation, review, and infrastructure – and the real client benefits, from faster turnaround to better-informed decisions.

Even a sophisticated subscription or success-based model cannot rescue a price that under-recovers costs or misjudges willingness to pay. A simple fixed fee for a clearly defined service can work well.

5. Many fixed fees are already there – disguised as T&M

Many engagements that look time-based already work like fixed-price deals: proposals list hours, often because procurement asks for them, but few projects bill hours times rate. The trap is recalculating the fee from shrinking hour estimates, which hands the efficiency gain straight to the client.

As we argued in Generative AI and the price model revolution in professional services – think golf not tennis, firms need a toolkit of pricing approaches rather than a single replacement for the billable hour.

Clients do not inherently value the 100 hours someone spent on their problem. They value what those hours achieve.

6. Fixed fees require a clearer definition of what is being sold

Charging for the garment means specifying the garment.

For a contract review, that means defining document volumes, complexity, review depth, turnaround, and expert validation. Broader coverage or faster delivery then becomes a priced choice instead of quiet scope creep.

In our Simon-Kucher project experience, some firms – especially law firms – expect AI gains to reach clients mainly as extra scope at stable or slightly higher rates. Others share them through lower fees.

But sharing the benefits does not necessarily mean offering the service at a discount.

Commercial execution: The tailor still has to make the sale

Even a clearly defined garment does not come with a self-evident price.

7. The best price reflects the client, the costs, and the competition

Value-based thinking is essential, but value alone does not determine the achievable price.

An urgent deadline makes faster AI-enabled delivery more valuable; a client sending far more contracts creates extra processing and review costs, even if human effort barely rises.

Competition matters too: if comparable offers command substantially higher prices, a firm may simply be undercharging.

8. Do not reward revenue that the firm cannot profitably deliver

Picture a partner paid on revenue while central IT absorbs the AI bill. The leaner team makes the project look more profitable, so the partner cuts the price to win more work. The firm, meanwhile, may under-recover the very costs behind its new delivery model.

The remedy has two parts:

a) Engagement economics need to reflect relevant AI costs.

b) Partner incentives need to reward sustainable, profitable pricing – not simply revenue, high utilization, or winning the mandate.

This is why The physics of pricing change treats cost visibility, governance, and partner enablement as integral to pricing transformation.

9. Partner pricing skills continue to make the difference

“You need less time because you are using AI, so why should I pay the same?” A technology invoice does not answer that. The partner has to explain what the client gets, what has improved, and how scope options change the price.

Sometimes the answer is a lower fee for productized work, sometimes broader scope or faster delivery. What matters is making that trade-off explicit instead of defaulting to the AI discount. Our project experience supports this: a few firms report significantly higher fees over the past 18 months.

Making the savings real

AI’s economic potential is real. But whether the savings materialize – and who ultimately captures them – depends on how firms adapt their commercial models.  

A practical starting point is one priority service. Establish its actual costs and client benefits. Rethink its scope and price. Pilot it in live opportunities. Then measure realized fees and margins after AI costs.

The emperor does not need another promise about his wardrobe. He needs something tangible. So do professional services firms.

To discuss how to prepare your organization for commercial success in the AI era, contact our Simon-Kucher experts today.

We would like to thank Philipp Preuss for his contribution to this article. 

Explore all the insights from our B2B Masterclass
Kontakt

Nehmen Sie Kontakt zu uns auf, unser Team berät Sie gerne.